Commission Dockets | previous page
EL18-053 - In the Matter of the Application of Deuel Harvest Wind Energy LLC for a Permit of a Wind Energy Facility and a 345-kV Transmission Line in Deuel County
Evidentiary Hearing Exhibits
Deuel Harvest Wind Energy LLC
- A1 - Application to the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission for Energy Facility Permits submitted by Deuel Harvest Wind Energy LLC, including Appendices A-W
- Appendix E - Level III Intensive Cultural Resources Survey Confidential (not available to the public)
- Appendix H - Interconnection Area Siting Study Confidential (not available to the public)
- Appendix T - Historical/Architectural Survey Confidential (not available to the public)
- A2 - Direct Testimony of Michael Svedeman
- A2-1 - Exhibit 1: Resume
- A3 - Direct Testimony of Andrea Giampoli
- A3-1 - Exhibit 1: Resume
- A4 - Direct Testimony of Michael Hankard
- A4-1 - Exhibit 1: Statement of Qualifications
- A5 - Direct Testimony of Michael MaRous
- A5-1 - Exhibit 1: Surrebuttal Testimony of David Lawrence on Behalf of the Staff of the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission, In Re the Matter of the Application by Dakota Range I, LLC and Dakota Range II, LLC for a Permit of a Wind Energy Facility in Grant County and Codington County, South Dakota, for the Dakota Range Wind Project - Docket No. EL 18-003
- A6 - Direct Testimony of JoAnne Blank
- A6-1 - Exhibit 1: Curriculum Vitae
- A7 - Supplemental Direct Testimony of Michael Svedeman
- A7-1 - Exhibit 1: Deuel Harvest Letter to SHPO, Dated February 5, 2019 Confidential (not available to the public)
- A7-2 - Exhibit 2: SHPO Email Dated February 5, 2019 and Deuel Harvest Response Dated February 7, 2019
- A8 - Supplemental Direct Testimony of JoAnne Blank
- A9 - Supplemental Direct Testimony of Michael Hankard
- A10 - Supplemental Direct Testimony of Andrea Giampoli
- A10-1 - Exhibit 1: Burns & McDonnell Memorandum, Eagle Nest Monitoring Near Lake Alice, South Dakota for the Deuel County North Wind Farm, Deuel County, South Dakota (February 11, 2019)
- A10-2 - Exhibit 2: Figure Showing Eagle Nest Near Lake Alice
- A11 - Supplemental Direct Testimony of Dr. Jeffrey Ellenbogen
- A11-1 - Exhibit 1: Statement of Qualifications
- A11-2 - Exhibit 2: Massachusetts Departments of Environmental Protection and Public Health (2012) - Wind Turbine Health Impact Study - Report of the Independent Expert Panel
- A11-3 Exhibit 3: Michaud, D. S. et al., Self-reported and Measured Stress Related Responses Associated with Exposure to Wind Turbine Noise. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 139, 1467-1479, doi:10.1121/1.4942402 (2016)
- A11-4 - Exhibit 4: Michaud, D. S. et al., Exposure to wind turbine noise: Perceptual responses and reported health effects. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 139, 1443-1454, doi:10.1121/1.4942391 (2016)
- A11-5 - Exhibit 5: Michaud, D. S. et al., Effects of Wind Turbine Noise on Self Reported and Objective Measures of Sleep. Sleep 39, 97-109, doi:10.5665/sleep.5326 (2016)
- A12 - Supplemental Testimony of Dr. Mark Roberts
- A12-1 - Exhibit 1: Statement of Qualifications Page 2 of 3 Listing of Applicant (Deuel Harvest Wind Energy LLC) Evidentiary Hearing Exhibits filed through 04/11/2019
- A12-2 - Exhibit 2: Letter, Kim Malsam-Rysdon, Secretary of Health, South Dakota Department of Health (Oct. 13, 2017) - In the Matter of the Application by Crocker Wind Farm, LLC for a Permit of a Wind Energy Facility and a 345 kV Transmission Line in Clark County, South Dakota, for Crocker Wind Farm - Docket No. EL17-055
- A12-3 - Exhibit 3: Crichton, F., et al. (2014). The link between health complaints and wind turbines: Support for the nocebo expectations hypothesis. Frontiers in Public Health 2:220
- A12-4 - Exhibit 4: Frits van den Berg, Public Health Service Amsterdam, and Irene van Kamp, National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (2017). Health effects related to wind turbine sound. Swiss Federal Office for the Environment
- A13 - Supplemental Direct Testimony of Jacob Baker
- A13-1 - Exhibit 1: Resume
- A14 - Rebuttal Testimony of Michael Svedeman
- A14-1 - Exhibit 1: Updated Project Layout
- A14-2 - Exhibit 2: Deuel County Official Zoning Map
- A14-3 - Exhibit 3: Deuel County Commissioners Meeting Minutes (March 28, 2017)
- A14-4 - Exhibit 4: Deuel Harvest Cultural Resources Study Plan, March 22, 2019
- A14-5 - Exhibit 5: SHPO Concurrence Letter, March 26, 2019
- A14-6 - Exhibit 6: Homan Airstrip and New Residence
- A14-7 - Exhibit 7: Figure of Removed Turbine Locations Since December 2017
- A15 - Rebuttal Testimony of Andrea Giampoli
- A15-1 - Exhibit 1: Updated BBCS
- A15-2 - Exhibit 2: South Dakota Natural Heritage Database Response, August 10, 2016
- A15-3 - Exhibit 3: South Dakota Natural Heritage Database Element Occurrence Record, August 10, 2016
- A16 - Rebuttal Testimony of Jacob Baker
- A16 - Rebuttal Testimony of Jacob Baker Confidential (not available to the public)
- A17 - Rebuttal Testimony of Michael Hankard
- A17-1 - Exhibit 1: Updated Pre-Construction Wind Turbine Noise Analysis for The Proposed Deuel Harvest North Wind Farm (March 2019)
- A18 - Rebuttal Testimony of JoAnne Blank
- A18-1 - Exhibit 1: Updated Shadow Flicker Analysis
- A19 - Rebuttal Testimony of Dr. Jeffrey Ellenbogen
- A19-1 - Exhibit 1: Moller M, Pedersen CS. Hearing at Low and Infrasonic Frequencies. Noise and Health. 2004
- A19-2 - Exhibit 2: Figure 9 of Moller M, Pedersen CS. Hearing at Low and Infrasonic Frequencies. Noise and Health. 2004
- A19-3 - Exhibit 3: Figure 15 of Moller M, Pedersen CS. Hearing at Low and Infrasonic Frequencies. Noise and Health. 2004
- A20 - Rebuttal Testimony of Michael MaRous
- A21 - Rebuttal Testimony of Benjamin Doyle
- A21-1 - Exhibit 1: Resume
- A21-2 - Exhibit 2: Capitol Airspace Group Obstruction Evaluation and Airspace Analysis March 26 2019
- A22 - Rebuttal Testimony of Cody Kenyon
- A23 - Rebuttal Testimony of Doyle Thompson
- A24 - Surrebuttal Testimony of Michael Hankard
- A25 - Surrebuttal Testimony of Dr. Jeffrey Ellenbogen
- A26 - Updated Land Ownership Map
- A27 - GE Safety Manual Confidential (not available to the public)
- A28 - GE Operating Manual Confidential (not available to the public)
- A29 - Applicant Updated Response to Commission Staff’s Data Request 2-6
- A30-1 - Applicant Responses to Intervenor John Homan’s First Set of Data Requests
- A30-2 - Applicant Responses to Intervenor John Homan’s Second Set of Data Requests
- A30-3 - Applicant Supplemental Responses to Intervenor Christina Kilby’s First Set of Data Requests
- A30-4 - Applicant Responses to Intervenor Christina Kilby’s Second Set of Data Requests
- A31-1 - Applicant’s First Set of Discovery Requests to Intervenor John Homan and Intervenor John Homan’s Responses
- A31-2 - Applicant’s Second and Third Sets of Discovery Requests to Intervenor John Homan and Intervenor John Homan’s Responses
- A31-3 Applicant’s Second Set of Discovery Requests to Intervenor Christina Kilby and Intervenor Christina Kilby’s Responses
- Revised A31-3 Applicant’s Second Set of Discovery Requests to Intervenor Christina Kilby and Intervenor Christina Kilby’s Responses
- A31-4 Applicant’s Third Set of Discovery Requests to Intervenor Christina Kilby and Intervenor Christina Kilby’s Responses
- A31-5 Applicant’s First Set of Discovery Requests to Intervenor Heath Stone and Intervenor Heath Stone’s Responses
- A31-6 Applicant’s Second and Third Sets of Discovery Requests to Intervenor Garrett Homan and Intervenor Garrett Homan’s Responses
- Exhibit A34 - FAA Traffic Pattern for Cat. A Map
- Exhibit A35 - 20:1 Surfaces for 00SD Map
- Exhibit A36 - Deuel County Commission Meeting Minutes May 16 and May 23 2017
- Exhibit A37 - Applicant’s and Staff’s Proposed Permit Conditions
- A38 - Distance from Residences to the Nearest Wind Turbine, Modeled Shadow Flicker and Sound Levels
- A39 - Updated Figures A-2 and A4-A
- A40 - Emails regarding Ice Build-Up on Blades
- A41 - Request for Interpretations of Deuel County Zoning Ordinance
- A42 - FAA's Central Region AIP Sponsor Guide
- A43 - Thomas M. Rice's Resume
- A44 - Runway Safety Areas Maps
- A46 - Distance to Turbines From 00SD
- S1 - Testimony of Jon Thurber and Exhibits
- S1 - Testimony of Jon Thurber and Exhibits Confidential (not available to the public)
- S2 - Rebuttal Testimony of Jon Thurber and Exhibits (Public)
- S2 - Rebuttal Testimony of Jon Thurber and Exhibits Confidential (not available to the public)
- S3 - Testimony of David Hessler and Exhibit
- S4 - Testimony of Tom Kirschenmann and Exhibits
- S5 - Testimony of Paige Olson and Exhibit
- S6 - Additional Intervenor Responses to Staff Data Requests
- S7 - Applicant’s Additional Data Request Responses to Staff
- S7 - Applicant’s Additional Data Request Responses to Staff Confidential (not available to the public)
- S8 - Locations of Turbines at Deuel Harvest in Relation to Wetlands
- Christina Kilby's Exhibits
- K1 - Rand Rebuttal Testimony
- K2 - Environmental Research
- K4 - Occupational Health and Industrial Wind Turbines, Rand, R., et. al.
- K5 - Physiological Effects of Infrasonic Emissions, Schomer, P., et. al.
- K8 - Wind Turbine Acoustic Investigation, Ambrose, A., Rand, R., and Krogh, C.
- K9 - Kilby Responses to Staff’s First Set of Data Requests
- K10 - Kilby Responses to Applicant’s First Set of Data Requests
- K11 - Kilby Responses to Staff’s Second Set of Data Requests
- K14 - Testimony of Christina Kilby Redacted
- K15 - Kilby Rebuttal Testimony, excluded portions marked
- K 16 - Andre et. al v. Invenergy
- Certificate of Service for Exhibits K9, K10, K11, K15 and K16
- K17 - Opinion and Order, Williams v. Invenergy
- K19 - Duel Harvest’s Responses to Christina Kilby’s First Set of Data Requests
- K20 - Deuel County Zoning Ordinance Table of Contents
- K21 - Deuel County Zoning Ordinance
- K23 - Deuel Harvest's Response to Christina Kilby's Second Set of Data Requests
- K24 - Invenergy Letter to Board of Adjustment regarding Homan Field
- K26 - Dan Litchfield Emails and Letter (Redacted)
- K27 - Applicant's Supplemental Responses to Kilby's First Set of DR
- K29 - A Cooperative Measurement Survey
- John Homan's Exhibits
- 04/12/19 - John Homan's Witness List and Request for Witness Scheduling
- JH27 - John Homan’s County Permit to Homan Field Landing Strip
Un-numbered John Homan’s Rebuttal Testimony to Jon Thurber’s Testimony - JH29 - Applicant’s Response to Intervener John Homan’s 2nd Set of Data Request
- JH30 - 5 FAA Sheets Un-numbered Applicant’s Response to Intervener John Homan’s 3rd Set of Data Request
- JH31 - John Homan’s Statement at Public Input Meeting and Attachments (Redacted)
- JH32 - Applicant’s Response to Interveners John Homan’s 1st Set of Data Requests Un-numbered George Holborn’s Response to 2nd Set of Data Request to John Homan
- JH27 - John Homan’s County Permit to Homan Field Landing Strip
- Heath Stone's Exhibits
- HS1 - Bald Eagle Nest Survey Forms
- HS2 - Iowa State University - Ring-Necked Pheasant Responses to Wind Energy in Iowa
- HS4 - Direct Testimony of Intervenor Heath Stone
- HS5 - Applicant’s Responses to Heath Stone’s First Set of Data Requests
- HS6 - Applicant’s Responses to Heath Stone’s Second Set of Data Requests
- HS7 - Heath Stone’s Responses to Applicant’s First Set of Data Requests
- HS8 - Heath Stone’s Responses to Applicant’s Second Set of Data Requests
- HS9 - Heath Stone’s Responses to PUC Staff’s First Set of Data Requests
- HS10 - Heath Stone’s Responses to PUC Staff’s Second Set of Data Requests (Redacted)
- Garrett Homan's Exhibits
- G1 - Garrett Homan Pre-filed Testimony
- G2 - GH Testimony Exhibit A - Figures 1-4
- G4 - GH Testimony Exhibit B - COPA/SMS Aviation Safety-Risk Assessment of The Effect of Wind Turbines on General Aviation Aircraft Confidential (not available to the public)
- G5 - GH Testimony Exhibit D - Wind Turbine Wake Aerodynamics
- G6 - GH Testimony Exhibit F - GE Safety Manual Confidential (not available to the public)
- G9 - Garrett Homan Rebuttal Testimony
- G10 - Kevin R. Elwood Statement Deuel Harvest Hearing
- G11 - Elwood Statement App #1 - WS of Kevin Elwood
- G12 - Elwood Statement App #2 - ERT1603603
- G14 - Elwood Statement App #4 - COPA Turbine Position Paper
- G17 - GH Comments Deuel Harvest Ice Throw
- G19 - GHoman Response to Staff’s DR1
- G20 - GHoman Response to Staff’s DR2 (Redacted)
- G21 - Applicant (Deuel) Response to Intervenor Homan Garrett Set 01
- G22 - GHoman Response to Applicant’s DR1
- G23 - GHoman Response to Applicant’s DR2 and DR3
- G24 - Deuel’s Response to Garrett Homan’s Second Set of Data Requests
- G25 - Classification of Wind Farm Turbulence and Its Effects on General Aviation Aircraft and Airports
- G26 - Coalescing Wind Turbine Wakes
- G27 - Risk Assessment Matrix
- G29 - NTSB CEN14FA224 Full Narrative
- Otter Tail Power Company's Exhibits
- Jon Henslin's Exhibits
- Will Stone's Exhibits
