Commission Dockets | previous page
CIV04-3014 - Verizon Wireless LLC, CommNet Cellular License Holding LLC, Missouri Valley Cellular, Inc., Sanborn Cellular, Inc., and Easter South Dakota Cellular, Inc. d/b/a Verizon Wireless v. South Dakota Public Utilities Commission, Defendants.
Date Filed: 08/09/04 ♦ Docket Closed: 12/28/07
Open Docket Closed Docket
- 08/09/04 - Letter to SD Public Utilities Commission from Lynn, Jackson, Shultz & Lebrun, P.C. and Summons in a Civil Action
- 08/09/04 - Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief
- 08/09/04 - Corporate Disclosure Statement
- 08/09/04 - Letter from Lynn, Jackson, Shultz & Lebrun, P.C.
- 08/09/04 - Motion to Admit Philip R. Schenkenberg Pro Hac Vice
- 08/09/04 - Affidavit of Philip R. Schenkenberg for Admisison Pro Hac Vice
- 08/09/08 - Motion to Admit David C. McDonald Pro Hac Vice
- 08/09/04 - Affidavit of David C. McDonald Pro Hac Vice
- 08/19/04 - Admission of Service
- 08/30/04 - Letter from Lynn, Jackson, Shultz & Lebrun, P.C. and Amended Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief
- 09/03/04 - Letters from SD Public Utilities Commission and Answer to Amended Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief and Certificate of Service
- 10/04/04 - Letter to Clerk of Courts and Motion to Intervene as Defendants (South Dakota Telecommunications Association and Venture Communications Cooperative)
- 10/04/04 - Answer of Intervenors
- 10/04/04 - Certificate of Service
- 10/20/04 - United States District Court Memorandum
- 10/21/04 - Letter to Judge Kornmann from Briggs and Morgan
- 11/01/04 - Letter to Judge Kornmann - Response from Briggs and Morgan to Court's Memorandum of October 20, 2004.
- 11/2/04 - Letter to Judge Kornmann - Response from SD Public Utilities Commission to Court's Memorandum of October 20, 2004.
- 11/17/04 - Letter to Judge Kornmann from Briggs and Morgan
- 1/11/05 - Order
- 03/07/05 - Letter to Judge Kornmann from Riter, Rogers, Wattier & Brown, LLP
- 05/01/05 - Letter notifying change of address
- 07/12/05 - Notice of Change of Adress
- 07/13/05 - Certificate of Service
- 07/13/05 - Letter and Initial Disclosure Under Rule 26(a)
- 07/13/05 - Letter and Plaintiff's Rule 26(a) Disclosures
- 07/13/05 - Letter and Joint Written Report of Rule 26(f) Meeting
- 07/13/05 - Rule 16 Scheduling Order
- 07/18/05 - Letter and Plaintiff's first set of interrogatories, requests for production of documents and requests for admission
- 07/21/08 - Amended Rule 16 Scheduling Order
- 07/29/05 - Letter from Briggs and Morgan regarding expert witnesses
- 08/02/05 - Letter and Disclosure of Expert Witnesses Pursuant to Rule 26(a)(2)
- 08/05/05 - Letter and Stipulation and Motion for Protective Order
- 08/05/05 - Proposed Protective Order
- 08/05/05 - Certificate of Service
- 08/10/05 - Memorandum from Judge Kornmann
- 08/17/05 - Certificate of Service
- 09/2/05 - Letter and Expert Report prepared by Larry D. Thompson of Vantage Point Solutions
- 09/07/05 - Certificate of Service
- 09/17/05 - Certificate of Service
- 10/17/05 - Certificate of Service
- 10/31/05 - Letter and Plaintiffs' Unopposed Motion for Protective Order
- 10/31/05 - Memorandum in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for Protective Order
- 10/31/05 - Plaintiffs' Notice of Motion for Protective Order
- 10/31/05 - Affidavit of Doug Miller in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for Protective Order
- 10/31/05 - Proposed Order Granting Plaintiffs' Motion for Protective Order
- 11/02/05 - Order Granting Plaintiffs' Motion for Protective Order
- 11/03/05 - Affidavit of Doug Miller in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for Protective Order
- 11/17/05 - Letters and Plaintiff Motion for Summary Judgment
- 11/17/05 - Plaintiff's Memorandum of Law In Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
- 11/17/05 - Affidavit of Philip R. Schenkenberg
- 11/17/05 - Affidavit of Jeff Harmon
- 11/17/05 - Affidavit of John L. Clampitt
- 11/17/05 - Affidavit of Edward A. Harrop
- 11/17/05 - Affidavit of Doug Miller (Confidential not available to public not on file at PUC)
- 11/17/05 - Proposed Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment
- 11/18/05 - Letter and Signature Page for Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment and Signature page for Plaintiffs' Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
- 12/05/05 - Letter and Motion for Enlargement of Time for Response and Amendment of Rule 16 Scheduling Order
- 12/14/05 - Second Amended Rule 16 Scheduling Order
- 12/14/05 - Order
- 12/23/05 - Letter and Reply of Defendant and Intervenors to Summary Judgment Motion of Verizon Wireless
- 12/23/05-Defendant's and Intervenors' Statement of Facts
- 12/23/05 - Response of Defendant and Intervenors to Plaintiff's Statement of Facts
- 12/23/05 - Certificate of Service
- 01/11/06 - Letter regarding Motion to strike portions of Larry Thompson's affidavit
- 01/19/06 -Letter regarding filing of 01/19/06
- 01/19/06 - Plaintiff's Reply Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
- 01/19/06 - Second Affidavit of Philip R. Schenkenberg
- 04/03/06 - Notice of Appearance For Craig A Pfeifle
- 04/07/06 - Third Amended Rule 16 Scheduling Order
- 04/19/06 - Fourth Amended Rule 16 Scheduling Order
- 05/18/06 - Fifth Amended Rule 16 Scheduling Order
- 05/18/06 - Sixth Amended Rule 16 Scheduling Order
- 05/18/06 - Memorandum from Judge Kornmann
- 05/24/06 - Letter from Gene N. Lebrun
- 05/25/06 - Letter from Gene N. Lebrun
- 06/9/06 - Letter from Darla Pollman Rogers
- 08/25/05 - Seventh Amended Rule 16 Scheduling Order
- 10/11/06 - Letter and Plantiff's Rule 26(a) Disclosures , as Supplemented October 6, 2006
- 10/11/06 Plaintiff Verizon Wireless' Supplemental Answers to Intervenors' and Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories
- 10/11/06 - Affidavit of Service by Mail
- 12/12/06 - Letter From Philip R. Schenkenberg to Darla Rogers and Rolayne Wiest Regarding Expert Report
- 10/13/06 - Opinion & Order on Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgement.
- 01/03/07 - Eighth Amended Rule 16 Scheduling Order
- 01/17/07 - Letter and Expert Report of Larry Thompson
- 02/02/07 - Motion to Continue and Motion for Additional Discovery
- 02/06/07 - Plantiffs' Third Set of Interrogatories and Second Set of Requests for Production of Documents
- 02/15/07 - Verizon Wireless' Response to Motion to Continue and Motion for Additional Discovery
- 02/22/07 - Letter to Kathy Hammond
- 02/23/07 - Reply to Verizon Wireless' Response to Motion to Continue and Motion for Additional Discovery
- 02/27/07 - Verizon Wireless' Request for Leave to File Record Clarification Regarding Motion To Continue and Motion for Additional Discovery
- 03/06/07 - United States District Court Memorandum
- 03/15/07 - Telephonic Pretrial Conference Memo
- 03/23/07 - Order Fixing Trial Dates
- 03/23/07 Telephonic Pretrial Conference Memo
- 06/11/07 - Amended Order Fixing Trial Dates
- 06/13/07 - Verizon Wireless' Motion in Limine
- 06/13/07 - Verizon Wireless' Memorandum in Support of Motion in Limine
- 06/13/07 - Affidavit of Philip R. Schenkenberg in Support of Motion in Limine
- 06/13/07 - Proposed Order Granting Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine
- 07/03/07 - Response to Verizon Wireless' Motion in Limine
- 07/27/07 - Letter and Stipulation of Facts
- 07/31/07 - Defendants' List of Trial Witnesses and Proposed Exhibits
- 07/31/07 - Verizon Wireless' Exhibit and Witness List
- 07/31/07 - Intervenors list of Trial Witnesses and Proposed Exhibits
- 08/01/07 - Memorandum from Judge Kornmann
- 08/01/07 - Letter to Kathy Hammond
- 08/01/07 - Letter to Judge Kornmann
- 08/06/07 - Order Granting Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine
- 08/08/07 - Letter and Notice of Appearance (Richard D. Coit)
- 08/30/2007 - Transcripts of Court Trial is as follows:
- Volume I Held on 08/15/07 (Not Available to the Public)
- Volume II Held on 08/16/07 (Not Available to the Public)
- Index (Not Available to the Public)
- 09/26/07 - Plaintiff's Proposed Findings of Fact
- 09/26/07 – Plaintiffs' Post Hearing Brief
- 10/02/07 – Stipulated Motion to Remove the State of South Dakota as A Party
- 10/02/07 [Proposed] Order Granting Stipulated Motion to Remove the State of South Dakota as A Party
- 12/28/07 - Opinion and Order
